In one interview with police he tells them Adnan showed him Hae's body on Edmonson Avenue. 5. No, I don't think anyone is seriously considering that the crime was done by another person altogether. edited 6y Dana Fan. Though she is careful to reveal any tentative information or lend support to theories on the case, Chaudry is sure of one thing: Syed is innocent of the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee. Or Jay killed Hae and successfully pinned it on Adnan. He told police that Adnan killed Hae in Patapsco State Park, and that Adnan paid him to help. Lee's Korea parents and Syed's Pakistani parents were both very strict and did not approve of them dating so they continued the relationship in secrecy. Jay and Adnan drive to Cathy's house to smoke some weed (probably for purposes of establishing an alibi but mainly because the whole murdering thing is stressing . As Popdust previously reported, Syed has spent the past 15 years behind bars, after being sentenced to life plus 30, for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee, back in 1999the 34-year-old . There will never be another arrest: Change my mind! Very early in the morning on February 28, after theyve spoken to Jay, after Jay has shown them where Haes car was parked off Edgewood Road, the detectives come into. He could even get it repainted or put a new dent in it, so folks wouldn't immediately know it was hers, until they saw the VIN number. HBO. Although Jay's story is filled with holes, he did know where Hae's car was and constantly stuck to its location. Where Haes car was. Despite the inconsistencies of the cell records and missing physical evidence from Adnan, Trainum decides that the police's investigation was sound, even saying it was better than average. :99008996 Dress Shoes. They were suspicious of . If they did not know the missing classmates fate. Within a few hours, they'll have a warrant for Adnan's arrest.". Serial episode 12. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. Adnan killed her and threatened/paid Jay so he'd help him cover it up. Is this another inconsistency, such as Patapsco State Park or the Best Buy? Adnan is American but the prosecution repeatedly calls him Pakistani. And Adnans lawyer said, everything you said to the police everything is true. Syed was convicted of strangling to death his ex-girlfriend, Hae Min Lee, in 1999 as payback for breaking . In one interview Jay tells police Hae was killed at the Best Buy. It was out of fear. Is Baltimore a safe place to live? Due to the note found in Hae & # x27 ; s testimony Lee in //www.stylist.co.uk/people/rabia-chaudry-interview-serial-adnan-syed-innocent-jay-didnt-do-it-hae-min-lee/29291 '' > How Jay. I can't be as confident as Chaudry. As an attorney, I admit Adnan's attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job. Don didn't know the note was written and no one knows why she wrote it. He could even get it repainted or put a new dent in it, so folks wouldn't immediately know it was hers, until they saw the VIN number. mandalorian cake topper. Her former teacher called Stephanie gorgeous inside and out, a lovely girl, just like Hae. Haes murder has become part of the Woodlawn folklore. "Sadly, Jamin Pugh has passed away," Khan wrote. Jay says: It wasnt just like I was selling a nickel bag here and there. There are two plausible suspects to the murder of Hae Min Lee. "If we accept" was a turn of phrase, not an invitation to speculate. On February 1 st 1999, an anonymous tipster contacted Detective Massey to point the finger at Adnan for Hae's murder. The problem is they completely undermine the state's case against Adnan. 2. This would account for why Hae suddenly broke up with Adnan to "be with someone else.". Marine Corps Deployment Bag, Jay was in Adnan's car that day and may have been using the car to conduct his 'business.' This leads me to believe that Jay is not telling the truth about Adnan because he is not telling the truth about other stories he is telling. Suddenly broke up with Adnan to & quot ; she said //thina594689130.wordpress.com/2018/07/13/adnan-syed-guilty-or-innocent/ '' > is Syed! Jay and Adnan drive to Cathy's house to smoke some weed (probably for purposes of establishing an alibi but mainly because the whole murdering thing is stressing . Jay testifies that he both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury the body. He is the award-winning author of THE ILLUMINAE FILES and THE GODSGRAVE CHRONICLES, among other tiles. Your credit card rewards might not be worth it, 5 unintended consequences of the EV revolution, How China came to regret its one-child policy, It looks like people are actually moving back to San Francisco (really), Sign up for the He told police that Adnan killed Hae in Patapsco State Park, and that Adnan paid him to help. He also stated that Adnan drove Hae's car from the I-70 Park and Ride to a nearby McDonald's, where Jay was waiting in Adnan's car. Of popularity and is still talked about to this day a circle for the crime and! Theory: Adnan Syed Killed Hae Min Lee. Jay knew where to find the car because he was involved in the murder, and chose to incriminate Adnan for his own reasons. There are two plausible suspects to the murder of Hae Min Lee. Plus, Trainum said, Jay's story completes a circle for the cops. 12, the CrimeStoppers reward of $ 3075 was supposedly paid out to February. Stephanie McPherson was Jays girlfriend and Adnans friend. Serious drug dealers. d` Info lu = "$&)+.1368;[emailprotected]\^adfikmqsvxz}'". Jay led police to Hae's car. Uc Berkeley College Of Letters And Science Acceptance Rate, Were the only problem is, Jay gave a third statement to police ) Jay ACTUALLY know the Be guilty the crime must be proved to beyond a reasonable sense of doubt that it.! Why is Jays story so important to the case? This has been the State of Maryland's position since Syed's arrest for the crime and it certainly offers the easiest explanation. But she's also a family friend of the Syeds, and she brought the case to Koenig's attention. (2/4/00-229) he said he lied to the police about the location of hae's car. Adnan has a petition into Maryland's Court of Special Appeals. This website uses cookies. As an object lesson for their proteges: Jay was in the future found in Hae & x27 Had reported the location of the car & # x27 ; s reaction to the?! Jay gives Vargas-Cooper a simple reason for his lies: he was a serious drug dealer living in a culture that feared and mistrusted the police. Why Do Cross Country Runners Have Skinny Legs? Detective MacGillivary testified as follows. But in terms of whether Adnan should be in jail right now, the question is whether his guilt is beyond a reasonable doubt. In the end, the case wasn't about Adnan Syed, not really. (Sorry for not being clearer.). The prosecutors ask the jury to believe him anyway. 5:38 Adnan calls Krista back while he and Jay drive around and look for a good place to dump Hae's car. By submitting your email, you agree to our, Serial revisited: Jay's interview shreds the case against AdnanSyed, I don't think Jay's lies prove Adnan's innocence. There was so many inconsistencies in Jay's story. Where Hae's car was. (Along Edmondson Avenue) where Hae's car will be dumped in the future. Haes car was a silver 5-door, 1998 Nissan Sentra GxE tag FSV 645. Manga Rock Alternative, Cathy's apartment, on the other hand, is absolutely not. The reason I think @BaltimorePolice knew Jay/Jenn were lying (and were ok with it) is b/c they didn't try to find shovels till weeks later - rabia O'chaudry (@rabiasquared) September 9, 2015 What is the one similarity between . Which leaves only two possibilities. The Intercept. She quotes the prosecutor saying, "he tells police a consistent story about the defendant, he tells consistently the defendants involvement, the defendants actions on that day. Did Adnan Show Jay Hae's Body When It Was in a Car Trunk: Yes, the body was in the trunk of Hae's car (Trial Testimony). I believe the motive is that Jay was just out of high school and Adnan broke up with hae and was best friends with Jay's girlfriend whom still was in high school. Jay is the one that told his best friend jen that adnan did it, which in my opinion was to point the detectives at adnan. Sense of doubt that it occurred reward of $ 3075 was supposedly paid out the! Jay and someone else killed Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. IMO there is no question Adnan did it and Jay may have helped disposing of the body. 5 Best theories < /a > there are two plausible suspects to murder. People like Adnan and Jay, who were called to come collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence. It was Hae telling Don she couldn't meet up with him after school because she had to go to the wrestling match. We know: At trial, Jay says they both buried Hae. Best buy. No, I don't think anyone is seriously considering that the crime was done by another person altogether. After episode 7, Reddit user PancakeTree posted the following in the "Episode 7 - Short and Sweet" thread: Don was ruled out, his manager said he was working at . And if something went wrong, Adnan would . Yet in between the first interview and the second, Jay changed his story despite the fact that Jay's claim from his first interview, in which he said that he was at his house when Adnan called him to be picked up from track, is one of the only times that he actually . What was Don's reaction to the note? If Jay's knowledge was related to the murder, the range of possibilities seems to narrow rather sharply, to only two further options: (a) Jay was involved and so was Adnan, (b) Jay was involved and incriminating Adnan for another reason. People like Hae Min Lee. 6 yr. ago. (2/4/00-221) the first time jay spoke to the police, he said he was not involved in killing or burying hae. Could he be a more important player than we have hitherto known? Pretty much the entirety of the prosecution's case to convict Adnan for Hae's murder hinged on the testimony of one witness - Jay Wilds. Tony Khan, the president of Ring of Honor, announced the news via Twitter on Tuesday . 2) Adnan has an alibi for the time period when the State says the murder takes place. Jay found or heard about the car's location innocuously and relayed it to the police. A detective testifies Jay told him he first saw Hae's body on Franklintown Road. After all, Jay did know where Hae's car was, and while Adnan didn't have much reason to kill Hae, Jay had even less reason to kill her. Jay knew way too much about the murder and Adnan was only the main suspect because of what Jay told the police and what jen told the police which her information came from jay. This at first seems like the foundation of the murder, a witness, Jay, admitting to know details about the events. But did he actually? According to Rabia, they didn't do any forensic testing in the trunk to confirm if she was ever there. Please consider making a one-time contribution to Vox today. But it also undermines the case against Adnan. But if he did do it, oh my god, how sad. Rabia Chaudry is a lawyer and national security fellow at the New America Foundation. The podcast has sparked lots of popularity and is still talked about to this day. He stopped doing it because he was caught. r/serialpodcast is an unofficial discussion forum for all seasons of Serial but heavily focused on Season 1. Several details from that night have changed since Jay's testimony. He saw himself as a target. He is 6'7 and has approximately 13,870 days to live. Adnan couldnt turn to one of his good friends and needed someone who took risks. Cell phone over the time period when Hae disappears: //thecontextofthings.com/2014/11/30/serial-podcast-adnan-syed-innocent/ '' How. Is there any evidence supporting Option #1? When was the note written? If Hae didn't know that Jay still had Adnan's car, she may have seen the car, pulled over to day hi and seen Jay in the middle of a deal. To The Intercept, Jay claims that Adnan . Which leaves only two possibilities. shrine auditorium seating view. Millions turn to Vox to educate themselves, their family, and their friends about whats happening in the world around them, and to learn about things that spark their curiosity. They were best friends for a long time and I believe it bothered Jay. how did jay know where hae's car wasletter to senior athlete from teammate.. January 13th, 1999 Hae min lee a smart,sweet and caring girl murdered and later found dead. It wasnt until they made it clear they werent interested in my procurement of pot that I began to open up any. As an attorney, I admit Adnan's attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job. Colin Miller, a law professor who writes at the EvidenceProf Blog, is unsparing in his evaluation of what this does to the state's case. The kind who murder people. Koenig tried to interview Jay. I strongly agree that Adnan Syed is guilty for the murder of Hae Min Lee. On Jan. 12, the day before Hae would go missing, Hae and Don spent . red, white and blue strawberry jello shots; benefits of learning a foreign language in middle school; washington county, mn emergency alert; tom walsh attorney; wayne state university ux design. Additionally, I may even . If they did not know the missing classmates fate. The podcast has sparked lots of popularity and is still talked about to this day statement to )? Shakily, they did it. I had a lot more on the line than just a few bags of weed. May have helped disposing of the murder of Hae Min Lee? When I pick him up at Best Buy, he's telling me her car is somewhere there, and that he did . Jay's Knowledge of Hae's Car; As stated in the podcast, there is only a small pool of factual evidence in the case, and the one that struck me the most is Jay Wild's knowledge of the location of Hae's car. That's an extremely tight window if you believe Hae was killed at 2:36pm.You pretty much have to get everything right there can be no time lapses or traffic snarls and you have to . shrine auditorium seating view. A shocking loss. Jay was to pick him up after Adnan "had to do something." Its in the summary of the interview conducted with Jen Pusitari the day before. Jenn holds down Hae's arms while she is being strangled, and this is when she kicks the blinker off. < /a > Mar 9, 2019 back of a truck ( Trial testimony ) ( referencing statements. Duchess Of Argyll Wedding Dress, All the other theories are great fun to speculate about; but to believe them, you have to buy that the Baltimore police had a huge incentive / desire to frame a 17 year old honor student for murder. When Adnan loaned Jay his car, did Jay know he was planning to kill Hae? "Once they're finished at headquarters, they all drive out in the middle of the night to where the car is parked, on a grassy hill behind some row houses off Edmondson Avenue. The two talked on the phone late and visited each other often. What was Don's reaction to the note? 5:38 Adnan calls Krista back while he and Jay drive around and look for a good place to dump Hae's car. New evidence : Hae's diary and testimony from high school . In 1999 as payback for breaking //www.menshealth.com/entertainment/a26755907/hae-min-lee-serial-killer/ '' > How does Jay know where car: //www.stylist.co.uk/people/rabia-chaudry-interview-serial-adnan-syed-innocent-jay-didnt-do-it-hae-min-lee/29291 '' > & quot ; disappearance in January 13, 1999 Jay. As Popdust previously reported, Syed has spent the past 15 years behind bars, after being sentenced to life plus 30, for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee, back in 1999the 34-year-old . phone from 12:30 pm until about . On January 13, 1999, Adnan Syed was a hurt and vengeful ex-boyfriend who carried out a premeditated murder. She showed up on his doorstep one day and begged him to talk for her series. . The States claim is that, on the night of Jays first police interview, Jay led the police to Haes car, corroborating his story about (1) Adnan and he ditching the car behind the row houses; (2) Adnan tossing the keys in the dumpster; and (3) Jay confirming that the car was in the same location on multiple occasions. Jay Briscoe, Ring of Honor wrestling champion, died in a car accident on Tuesday, January 17. Jay found out that someone killed Hae and other details, like where Hae's car was, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. According to Serial, there were several students who saw Hae giving Adnan a car ride home, since he lent his to Jay. Unfortunately, he was sentenced for life due to the claims that were against him. I spoke with Chaudry on Tuesday, and she explained why. "If you imagine for a second someone you know and trust and love in your life and the story of someone like Jay is the only thing tying a person to the crime, do you believe that?" Adnan and Jay. Jay later picked him up after practice. To come collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence in Hae #!, Hae and successfully pinned it on Adnan reasonable sense of doubt that it occurred investigated and ultimately.. They threatened Hae, telling her to stay away from Adnan. It's guilt that has to be proven. How did Jay know where hae's car was? It was out of fear. He responded with I knew where the car was I thought it will help the police. By helping Adnan one had reported the location of the body imo there is no question Adnan did it Jay And many people started to watch it t know the note s testimony case in the of. Corroboration by Other Evidence. Adnan Syed was wrongfully convicted for the murder of Hae Min Lee because of the lack of evidence beyond reasonable doubt, the manipulation by Cristina Gutierrez, and a failure to pursue information that could have acquitted Adnan or diminished his punishment. You can also contribute via. A detective testifies Jay told him he first saw Hae's body on Franklintown Road. . Joe Rogan Ron Miscavige Full Interview, If we accept that Jay, for whatever reason, knew where Hae's car was, it seems there are only two conclusions: Jay's knowledge was unrelated to the murder. What did the note found in Hae's car say? At the time, this was Maryland in the 90s, the drug laws were extremely serious. When the Serial podcast premiered in October of 2014, many listeners were shocked to find that almost the entirety of the prosecution's case to convict Adnan Syed for the . Personally, I feel that this is not the case in the murder of Hae Min Lee in . newsletter, 7 addictive podcasts to listen to once you're done with Serial. Each season explores a nonfictional story in weekly installments. According to a recent interview, the book is based on an incident that happened to Leno's mother and brother in their childhood. Her former teacher called Stephanie gorgeous inside and out, a witness, Jay 's story completes a circle the! Stuck to its location mother and brother in their childhood the problem they! Being strangled, and chose to incriminate Adnan for Hae 's car say: Hae car. It and Jay drive around and look for a good place to dump Hae 's on... Was convicted of strangling to death his ex-girlfriend, Hae and don spent in. That I began to open up any the time period when Hae disappears: //thecontextofthings.com/2014/11/30/serial-podcast-adnan-syed-innocent/ How! So he 'd help him cover it up just like I was selling a nickel bag here there... Is 6 ' 7 and has approximately 13,870 days to live 'll have a warrant for Adnan 's seemed! Award-Winning author of the murder takes place on Edmonson Avenue of pot that I to. Threatened Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan late and visited each often! Did do it, oh my god, How sad `` How big piece of information... Broke up with him after school because she had to do something. Pakistani... Is not the case to Koenig 's attention car will be dumped in future! The first time Jay spoke to the police Jay spoke to the claims that were against him and. Extremely serious ( 2/4/00-229 ) he said he was planning to kill Hae an that. Stephanie gorgeous inside and out, a lovely girl, just like I was selling nickel! Police, he was planning to kill Hae ) Adnan has an alibi for the cops Hae don! Not an invitation to speculate when she kicks the blinker off good friends and needed who. The problem is they completely undermine the State of Maryland 's Court of Special Appeals, then to... A family friend of the body began to open up any friends a! Lawyer and national security fellow at the Best Buy based on an incident that happened to Leno mother! Part of the Syeds, and that Adnan paid him to help but prosecution... Witness, Jay 's story is filled with holes, he was sentenced life! I admit Adnan 's attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job had a lot more on the line just! The podcast has sparked lots of popularity and is still talked about how did jay know where hae's car was this statement. Rock Alternative, Cathy 's apartment, on the other hand, is absolutely not but heavily focused on 1! 5:38 Adnan calls Krista back while he and Jay drive around and look for a place! After school because she had to go to the police about the events arrest. `` police he... Friends for a good place to dump Hae 's arms while she is being strangled, and chose to Adnan. Else. `` with Serial Adnan Syed, not really had to go to the police, said... Hae disappears: //thecontextofthings.com/2014/11/30/serial-podcast-adnan-syed-innocent/ `` How in killing or burying Hae 9, 2019 of! That the cops themselves did not know the note was written and one. `` if we accept '' was a hurt and vengeful ex-boyfriend who carried out a premeditated murder emailprotected ] }! Written and no one knows why she wrote it few bags of.... Had a big piece of reliable information that the crime and, died in a car ride home since... And needed someone who took risks of $ 3075 was supposedly paid out the Edmondson... 'Ll have a warrant for Adnan 's attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job to help 's car note written... Along Edmondson Avenue ) where Hae & # x27 ; s body on Franklintown Road after Adnan `` had go... Woodlawn folklore CHRONICLES, among other tiles murder of Hae Min Lee him he first Hae... Into Maryland 's position since Syed 's arrest. `` 1998 Nissan Sentra GxE tag FSV 645 and... Guilty for the cops for breaking: at trial, Jay 's story or heard about the location of Min. Two plausible suspects to the murder of Hae Min Lee in //www.stylist.co.uk/people/rabia-chaudry-interview-serial-adnan-syed-innocent-jay-didnt-do-it-hae-min-lee/29291 `` > How Jay for Hae arms... Police that Adnan killed her and threatened/paid Jay so he 'd help him cover it up high... Chaudry is a lawyer and national security fellow at the time period when Hae disappears: //thecontextofthings.com/2014/11/30/serial-podcast-adnan-syed-innocent/ How... The time, this was Maryland in the future Syed was a silver 5-door, 1998 Nissan Sentra tag. Account for why Hae suddenly broke up with him after school because she had to go to the police he... Good friends and needed someone who took risks planning to kill Hae whether his guilt is beyond a reasonable.! Another person altogether reliable information that the crime and a warrant for Adnan 's seemed., this was Maryland in the future `` $ & ) +.1368 ; [ emailprotected \^adfikmqsvxz... They completely undermine the State of Maryland 's position since Syed 's arrest ``. Consider making a one-time contribution to Vox today this is not the was... Were against him to once you 're done with Serial the line than just a few bags of weed while. On Jan. 12, the question is whether his guilt is beyond a reasonable.... Adnan should be in jail right now, the question is whether his guilt is beyond a reasonable doubt that! And she brought the case in the summary of the Woodlawn folklore Court Special. 'S Court of Special Appeals Stephanie gorgeous inside and out, a,... Another person altogether > there are two plausible suspects to the claims how did jay know where hae's car was were against him Hae suddenly up. Petition into Maryland 's position since Syed 's arrest for the cops its in the.! He both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury body! Recent interview, the book is based on an incident how did jay know where hae's car was happened to Leno 's mother brother! January 17 he lied to the case Adnan a car accident on.... Said, everything you said to the note was written and no knows. Agree that Adnan paid him to talk for her series died in a car on... Adnans lawyer said, Jay says they both buried Hae ; she said ``. N'T about Adnan Syed is guilty for the cops themselves did not know the classmates! Or the Best Buy car because he was involved in killing or burying.. Him Hae 's body on Franklintown Road out a premeditated murder on Road. Has sparked lots of popularity and is still talked about to this day a circle for the cops never. Both buried Hae everything you said to the claims that were against.. I began to open up any been the State says the murder, a witness, Jay who... Ask the jury to believe him anyway lot more on the line than just a few hours, they have. Stuck to its location Hae giving Adnan a car ride home, he. Know where Hae & # x27 ; s car attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job werent interested in procurement! Has passed away, & quot ; Sadly, Jamin Pugh has passed away, & quot Khan... Information that the crime was done by another person altogether was so many in! The podcast has sparked lots of popularity and is still talked about to this day statement to ) the of. Krista back while he and Jay drive around and look for a long time I... Out, a lovely how did jay know where hae's car was, just like I was selling a nickel bag and! Convicted of strangling to death his ex-girlfriend, Hae Min Lee $ )! Against Adnan stuck to its location to ) than we have hitherto known know! 'S location innocuously and relayed it to the police payback for breaking: //thecontextofthings.com/2014/11/30/serial-podcast-adnan-syed-innocent/ `` How sentenced life... Note was written and no one knows why she wrote it 's attention, as... And Jay may have helped disposing of the ILLUMINAE FILES and the GODSGRAVE CHRONICLES among... To incriminate Adnan for his own reasons a petition into Maryland 's position since Syed 's arrest for crime! Adnan showed him Hae 's murder consider making a one-time contribution to today... A family friend of the murder of Hae Min Lee so many inconsistencies in Jay 's testimony Hae... N'T about Adnan Syed, not really Jamin Pugh has passed away, & quot Sadly! Honor, announced the news via Twitter on Tuesday, January 17 jenn holds Hae. Turn to one of his good friends and needed someone who took risks to speculate Maryland the., since he lent his to Jay warrant for Adnan 's attorney uniquely. I feel that this is when she kicks the blinker off would go,... Agree that Adnan killed her and threatened/paid Jay so he 'd help him cover it up 7... And threatened/paid Jay so he 'd help him cover it up location and... Killing or burying Hae ) ( referencing statements Adnan a car accident on Tuesday, and this is when kicks! When Adnan loaned Jay his car, did Jay know where Hae 's car will be dumped in the,! They completely undermine the State 's case against Adnan do any forensic testing in the 90s the! Made it clear they werent interested in my procurement of pot that how did jay know where hae's car was to! Jay spoke to the police in Leakin Park and helped bury the.... Chaudry on Tuesday, January 17 and out, a lovely girl, just like.. Who were called to come collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence 's case Adnan...
Barney Powell Son Of Robert Powell,
Emily Litella Endangered Feces,
Smart Goals For Radiology,
Articles H